Southeast Asia's nuclear ambitions hinge on early policy choices
These involve ownership, technology, fuel, and waste.
Southeast Asia must settle four decisions on ownership, technology, fuel, and waste now, or risk locking in costly outcomes for decades, according to a report by Ross Matzkin-Bridger of the Nuclear Threat Initiative (NTI), published by the Hinrich Foundation.
Matzkin-Bridger, Senior Director for Nuclear Materials Security at NTI, wrote that Vietnam, Indonesia, the Philippines, and Malaysia have all targeted the 2030s for first nuclear power generation.
On ownership, he wrote that host-country ownership carries greater responsibilities, including financing and the risk of cost overruns and delays, but “pays the most dividends” for countries that also want energy security, technical capacity, and a domestic workforce.
Foreign build-own-operate shifts construction and schedule risk to the vendor, but weakens the energy security rationale and limits capacity building, the report said.
On technology, countries aiming for power at scale within 15 years should focus on ready-to-deploy and on-the-cusp designs, including small modular reactors.
The report warned against “confusing deployable assets with science projects”.
On fuel, the report favoured a market-based approach that relies on multiple suppliers for each step of the supply chain.
Enrichment is a bottleneck, with Russia holding about 44% of global capacity, followed by Europe at 32%, China at 15%, and the US at 8%.
On waste, the report urged governments to set up a funding mechanism before producing any electricity and to plan interim spent fuel storage before building reactors.
It said reprocessing has failed to deliver on its promises, citing real-world recycle rates of zero to 2%. France, for instance, reuses about 1% of its spent fuel.
The report said regional coordination could cut costs and risks that individual national strategies would leave unaddressed.
It proposed four steps: consulting neighbours early on siting and technology, sharing safety and security practices, building regulatory capacity together, and forming a regional working group on waste.