,APAC

ADB’s coal retirement scheme is high-risk: analyst

Implementation challenges could lead to a loss of credibility for the bank.

Asian Development Bank’s plan to help speed up the retirement of high emissions coal-fired power plants in Southeast Asia comes with a high risk, according to a report by Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA).

The report’s co-author, Melissa Brown, said this announcement sets the stage for a transformation of the Asian multilateral development bank’s (MDB) role in guiding power infrastructure development in the region. 

With several other financial firms, ADB plans to build public-private funding vehicles to buy coal-fired power plants and retire them within 15 years to allow countries time to switch to renewable energy.

“COP26 is driving a new round of policy work by the MDB’s, and ADB is working hard to have a compelling solution on the table for donor nations to support,” said Brown.

The 2021 United Nations Climate Change Conference or COP26 is scheduled to be held between 31 October and 12 November this year.

Brown said that ADB has an important role to play because donor nations have struggled to find fundable transition initiatives in Southeast Asia’s strategically important energy growth markets, including the Philippines, Vietnam, Indonesia, and in South Asia, Bangladesh.

The ADB proposes an energy transition mechanism (ETM) focused on coal retirement. The report said that the ETM has the potential to be an innovative effort to match new sources of blended finance with high priority steps that Southeast Asian countries could take to decarbonize.

The report also added that ADB’s ETM program will inevitably be assessed based on its ability to build on new financial market trends and accelerate the reduction and elimination of climate risks for the stakeholders they serve.

“To meet these expectations and have a catalytic impact, the projects undertaken should also meet the highest standards of market governance and align with credible international coal phase-out goals. The stakes are high for all concerned because implementation challenges could rob the ADB of credibility and block funding for other equally important high impact clean energy funding strategies,” Brown said.

Critical issue

Another hurdle that ADB has to clear is the critical question of how much money would be needed to position an ETM program for success.

According to IEEFA’s report, if the goal was to use the ETM facility to support the early retirement of half of the coal fleet in Indonesia, the Philippines, and Vietnam, the total facility size could balloon to as much as $30b to $55b.

“The funding needed to support the scale-up of this program is dramatically higher than existing ADB clean energy financing programs,” report co-author Grant Hauber added.

Haiber said that matching the expansive goals in the ADB’s USD4.05 million technical assistance program with efforts to mobilize tens of billions of dollars from a mix of donor nations and financial investors would be ambitious under any circumstances.

“It will naturally raise questions about how this process can be managed to ensure that other, potentially more cost-effective proposals are not crowded out,” Hauber added.

Join Asian Power community
Since you're here...

...there are many ways you can work with us to advertise your company and connect to your customers. Our team can help you dight and create an advertising campaign, in print and digital, on this website and in print magazine.

We can also organize a real life or digital event for you and find thought leader speakers as well as industry leaders, who could be your potential partners, to join the event. We also run some awards programmes which give you an opportunity to be recognized for your achievements during the year and you can join this as a participant or a sponsor.

Let us help you drive your business forward with a good partnership!

The two will collaborate to assess the role of green hydrogen in India’s energy transition.
This was met by renewables as well as coal, and gas generation.
It forms part of a 470MW battery project.          
About 120GW of new solar and wind capacity is expected in 2022.  
The agreement includes exploration of offshore wind projects.
The growth rate stabilises following an 8% increase in 2021.
This is a 10-fold increase from the Philippines grid-connected solar capacity.
32 nuclear reactors under construction are expected to bring 30GW in electricity per year.
Without banking power, the business model of solar power becomes unviable.
It is ideal for India because of its geographical location and the socio-economic opportunities it will offer, IEEFA Contributor Charles Worringham argues.
It will look into the development of a 1.2GW solar capacity in Indonesia.
The joint venture will operate under the brand Solar Radiance.
This is to support the increasing demand, according to Wood Mackenzie.
The joint venture is expected to start operations in the first half of 2022.
The product will allow coverage of consequential loss due to damages on property during PV installation.